How big of a turn off is it more guys when a girls' makeup gets shiny?

After a while when I where foundation then sometimes it will get really shiny and it's super noticeable. I've tried all different moisturizers, cleansers, and foundations but nothing seems to fix the problem, so that's out of the question. My question is...is it a turn off for guys at all when a girls' foundation gets shiny? If at all, how much of one?? *GUYS OPINION PLEASE?*